OB.SESSED Archive
Back to archive

Marauders, Lancers both eye first victory in Week 4 matchup

McMaster travels to Windsor to face the Lancers on Saturday, September 13, as both programs look for their first win in 2025.

Header Photo: Edwin Tam/Marauders

At 7 p.m. on Saturday night, the 0-2 McMaster Marauders, fresh off their bye week, will square off against another 0-2 counterpart, the Windsor Lancers.

Preceding Mac's bye week were back-to-back losses to York on the road to start the season and then a 38-4 drubbing at the hands of the Queen's Gaels in the home opener.

On the other side, Windsor lost their opening game of 2025 on the road at Laurier, 30-9, followed by their home opener this past weekend, where they gave up an early lead to Guelph in a 31-17 home loss.

Windsor has the upper hand over McMaster in the last two meetings between these teams in 2023 and '21; however, every single game between the two before 2021 has been in favour of the maroon and white, as Mac won every matchup from 2009 to 2019.

One other fun little tidbit about the connection between these two programs concerns Lancers head coach Jean-Paul Circelli, who was an offensive lineman for the Marauders from 2001 to 2005. During that time, he enjoyed Yates Cup glory three times and served as team captain in his senior year.

Let's start with football's most important position: the quarterback. The Marauders and Lancers each possess a talented yet relatively green starting option in Luke Thalman and Nick Dimovksi, respectively.

In terms of the numbers, Thalman has the upper hand so far through two games with three touchdown passes and an impressive completion percentage mark of 68.1 per cent while Dimovski has totalled more yards, with 548 to only one touchdown, two picks, and a completion mark of 54.4 per cent.

They also both average 8.1 yards per attempt through the air.

Since both defences have each given up more passing yards than rushing yards thus far, this game presents a good opportunity for both signal-callers to air the ball out consistently.

Even though, from the outset, these teams appear to have primarily defensive identities, both teams' losses in 2025 have occurred when the opposing team scores 30 points or more.

Therefore, the X-factor in determining a winner will most likely come down to who can survive a shootout.

The Lancers' and Marauders' receiving corps will be busy on game day and will need to be productive after the catch so that their offences are in the best position possible to score points.

Fortunately for both teams, they have talented athletic pass-catchers who are capable of gaining extra yards when needed.

In particular, both teams' top receivers, Jackson Taylor and Kareame Cotton, will need to be on point in this game.

Taylor, this season, is the Marauder's leader in receiving yards (137) and touchdowns (two), just a season after he was named the Norm Marshall OUA Rookie of the Year award, while Cotton, an NCAA Division 1 transfer from Northwestern State University, is the Lancer's leader in the same categories with 173 yards and a touchdown.

Expect the Marauders' Aidan Nemeth and Everett Reid, as well as Windsor's Evan Martin and Colby Ginn, to be used in complementary ways to aid their offences. Reid and Martin also happen to lead their teams in catches so far.

Secondaries on both sides will need to be ready for anything that comes their way. Luckily for the Marauders and Lancers, they have some lockdown defensive backs in their arsenals.

Robert Springer, Windsor's fantastic cornerback, has already notched an interception this year against Laurier, just a season after recording four to lead the Lancers in 2024.

Istvan Assibo-Dadzie is also a great pass-defender opposite Springer, as he was named an OUA First-Team All-Star and a Second-Team All-Canadian last year.

For the Marauders, their secondary is loaded with a healthy mix of younger and older talent. Sean Underhill and Juan Vasquez, Mac's two outside corners, are highly talented and athletic defensive backs who play an aggressive brand of football.

Underhill also returns punts for the team, as exemplified by his brilliant 60-yard return in the first game against York.

The veteran presence comes from free safety Carter Blad and halfback Ethan Stuart, two seniors who have seen various offensive schemes in their many games playing for the Marauders. Stuart is also third on the team in tackles, as he is very adept at stopping the run.

McMaster has been using a mixture of Micah Duchene, Brayden Kelly, and a sprinkle of Owen Monaghan to power their rushing attack this season, which has brought mixed results.

Monaghan is the team's leading rusher; however, his total has come from only one single rush so far, with Duchene and Kelly each having carried the ball at least ten times.

Their efforts have not yielded much, though, as McMaster ranks last in Ontario and third from the bottom nationally in rushing first-down conversions, with just eight through two games.

Using a combination of the three would likely aid the Marauders best in this game, as they can swap them out when they seem to be lacking energy. Additionally, it forces the Lancer defence to adapt to different styles of rushing in real-time.

Windsor's rushing attack is a bit similar as well, with Weagbe Mombo and Andrew Delaney being the two leading rushers.

They each provide their own unique strengths, with Mombo being the fast and shifty back, while Delaney is more of a power-oriented runner.

This combo will force the Marauder linebacking corps and defensive line to be on their toes. Anthony Sestanovic, Aaron Lavers, and current team leader in tackles (17.5), Isaiah Shields, will have to nullify any chance Windsor has of establishing a solid tempo with the run.

The same goes for Domenic Limanni and Greg Palmer, the two interior defensive linemen who can use their massive frames to swallow up inside rushing gaps.

Lastly, it would be a personal affront to Lancer fans to discuss linebackers without mentioning Marco Piccioni and Dylan Simpson, two sideline-to-sideline playmakers who are constantly in the mix, regardless of whether it is a run or pass they are defending.

Both players have interceptions this year too, and their fellow linebacker, Matteo Santagapita, is second on the team in tackles so far with 14.

Accounting for those three at all times will be crucial for the Marauders if they hope to walk out of Windsor with a win.

Five performers to watch

Aidan Nemeth, WR, McMaster: Nemeth is a gem of a receiver with excellent all-around abilities. After not playing in the season opener away at York, Nemeth was one of the Marauders' bright spots in their Week 2 loss at home to Queen's, where he was the team's leading receiver with five catches for a tough 51 yards. If Jackson Taylor is utterly blanketed for the majority of this game by Windsor's defensive backs, Thalman may start to look Nemeth's way as a reliable safety valve.

Andrew Delaney, HB, Windsor: The thunder to Mombo's lightning, Delaney is a big body to bring down in any scenario. Depending on how the Lancers' coaching staff utilizes their running backs, Delaney has the chance to physically wear out the Marauders' defence, especially if they also consider the different style that Mombo brings when they are alternated.

Luke Thalman, QB, McMaster: In his first full season as the starter at Mac, Thalman has been pretty good so far in the face of their 0-2 start. A great field general, he has been completing his passes at an accurate 68 per cent mark and will face another stingy defence for the second game in a row. If he can help lead this team to a win in a harsh environment in Windsor, opinions may start to shift about the capabilities of the 2025 Marauders.

Kareame Cotton, WR, Windsor: In Windsor's last game, Cotton went off for 117 receiving yards, one touchdown, and averaged 23.4 yards per catch off just five receptions against a talented Guelph Gryphon defence. McMaster's secondary, though gifted, has struggled so far against the pass by giving up an average of 350.0 passing yards per game. If that vulnerability is still evident on Saturday night, Cotton could have another huge game.

Anthony Sestanovic, LB, McMaster: Sestanovic's presence as the middle linebacker will be crucial in stuffing run attempts and patrolling the middle for any crossing routes to some of Windsor's speedier receivers.

Nicolas Tazzeo

Writer, OUA

Nicolas is one of OB.SESSED's OUA writers. He comes from a background in broadcast journalism, attending the Dan Patrick School of Sportscasting at Full Sail University. He also serves as a volunteer at Cable 14 in Hamilton, Ontario.

Writer profile